Most home buyers and sellers consider themselves to be knowledgeable about real estate market trends because of what the media reports. However, because the media reports reflect nationwide home sales, their analysis is based on severely deficient data. In addition, the news can often be contradictory, giving us headlines such as the ones we saw this week: “Housing Report Disappoints as Sales Dip in February” and “Home Sales Show Strength, Prices Rise” and “Home Prices to Rebound in 2012”.
Where does this leave someone who’s specifically interested in the Little Silver and Oceanport housing market? In my opinion, the only way for a buyer or seller to make an informed decision is to talk to a Realtor who knows the local market and tracks local market activity. That way you can make a data-driven decision, rather than one based on emotions or an irrational response.
Even if you’re not currently thinking of buying or selling, you should be interested in local real estate trends because they impact your personal financial security. You track your stocks and 401(k) retirement savings, right? Doesn’t it make sense then to also track home values?
Well, how do you do that? To make it easy, I’ve done some extensive research and I’m going to share the information with you. Today I’ll give you the annual statistics for 2011 vs. 2010, and in a subsequent post I’ll update you for the first quarter in 2012. And the information I’ll share with you will be local data for Little Silver and Oceanport. I want you to have objective information about the 4 key real estate indicators:
1. Sales Activity (Demand) - How many properties sold last year as compared to the year before (or the 2012 quarter to the same quarter in 2011). If sales are increasing, prices are likely to increase as well; if sales are declining, prices may continue to decline.
2. Listing Activity (Supply) - The number of homes for sale in your area. If the number is increasing using the same year-over-year comparison as above, prices are likely to drop to absorb the additional inventory; if the inventory is dropping, it may not be long before prices increase.
3. Months’ Supply of Homes for Sale (Absorption Rate) – A calculation of the number of months it would take to sell the current supply of homes if home sales continue at the present rate. A “normal market” is usually 5 - 7 months for average priced homes, and tends to increase as you move into the higher price ranges. We’ve been in a “buyer’s market” (greater than 7 months) for the past few years. If the supply is trending back to the 5 -7 months average, home prices may be increasing.
4. Average or Median Sales Price (Value) - The prices of homes sold last year/quarter compared with the previous year/quarter. If prices have dropped, they may continue to drop in the future. If prices have stabilized or have started to increase, an increase in the future may be at hand.
Be warned, however, that sometimes the 4 indicators may send conflicting signals. I’d be glad to talk with you when this happens. Today let’s look at the 2011 annual data:
Town Year Sales Active Listings Months’ Supply Average Price Median Price
Little 2011 62 44 9.8 months $ 600,056 $ 522,500
Silver 2010 74 50 11.4 months $ 676,581 $ 550,000
Oceanport 2011 55 40 10.0 months $ 531,843 $ 440,000
2010 46 41 11.4 months $ 601,135 $ 487,500
Monmouth 2011 3,929 3,851 11.8 months $ 482,057 $ 375,500
County 2010 3,970 4,124 12.5 months $ 503,955 $ 393,250
So for Little Silver, Oceanport and Monmouth County as a whole there were both positive signals (indicated in bold font) and negative signals (indicated in italic font). Next week we’ll look at the statistics for the first quarter of 2012.
Dentss Dunnagun
5:06 am on Thursday, April 5, 2012
With the second foreclosure tsunami about to hit it will make people buying now very sorry .I'm not sure how this affects LS but if it's cheaper to buy in one of the surrounding by 20% or more LS prices still have a way to drop .The real wild card here is the reassessment in LS ,with the town already having the highest taxes vs real value it will only get worst especially on the already battered high end .I know of at least one builder that will not even build on spec in town just because of the high taxes .We still have not returned to 2002 (presently at 2003-04)prices which is the affordable level for people with jobs . Correct me if I'm wrong ..
Len Dunikoski, GRI
1:00 pm on Thursday, April 5, 2012
Lots of factors affect home values in a given town. You're correct in saying that 2011 prices of Little Silver single-family homes were lower than they were in 2003, but not as low as they were in 2002. However, it's hard to predict whether they'll go down any further. For example, in Oceanport, 2011 home prices were higher than they were in 2003 and in Fair Haven they were higher than they were in both 2003 and 2004. It's certainly unusual for home prices to be where they were 8, 9 or 10 years ago, when historically home values have increased 3% - 5% per year.
- Len
Dentss Dunnagun
10:53 am on Friday, April 6, 2012
Len, simple reason for lower prices in LS ...PROPERTY TAXES !!!!! the only way for real estate to recover is through rising wages or home prices falling to affordable levels ,I saw a chart a while ago of the average household income in LS it's about 150K times that by 3 and there is your affordable home price 450 ...give or take
Don
12:57 pm on Friday, April 6, 2012
Len and Dentss, I haven't done my homework on this subject matter but would you know how much property taxes are for a home in LS that's say worth 500K (with basically the same size property/bedrooms/baths) compared to say Rumson and Fair Haven with a home value at 500K? The 500K is just an example. Are we talking a couple of percentage points higher in taxes or much more? I'll try and see if I can locate some data on this but perhaps you already know the answer.
Len Dunikoski, GRI
1:25 pm on Friday, April 6, 2012
Don, the answer isn't as simple as you might think it should be. On one hand, let's look at 4 homes that sold for about the same prices in the first quarter of 2012:
Fair Haven: MLS #21132014; 1,644 sq ft, sold for $450,000; taxes $9,927
Little Silver: MLS #21135526; 2,055 sq ft, sold for $470,000; taxes $8,535
Oceanport: MLS #21134567; 2,348 sq ft, sold for $467,500; taxes $7,509
Rumson: MLS #21183202; 1,584 sq ft, sold for $475,000; taxes $5,720
On the other hand, had you been able to move any of these homes to the other 3 nearby towns, they would have sold for very different prices. In general, if housing values in a town are higher, that town will have lower taxes; in a town where you get "more house for the money" (i.e., lower purchase price), you'll pay higher taxes. In other words, pay me now or pay me later. Hope this helps.
- Len
Dentss Dunnagun
4:44 pm on Friday, April 6, 2012
Len ,you are quite correct ,I have been looking in sea girt where a house sold for 535 K and the taxes were 5K and spring lake a sold home for 550K it's taxes were $3,200 . but the average selling price in both those towns were 1 million .Me I would opt for the lower taxes and higher home price ,at least you have a chance of recouping 20 years of taxes when you sell ...taking your #'s buying in LS at 470K with 8,500 in taxes in 20 years is over 170K (with NO tax increases ) where as in Spring lake that 's 64K in taxes over 20 years ...and we all know what has really happened with property taxes in the last 20 years ...how about 150% ....at least in my town little silver